Banner in the Sky: A Newbery Honor Award Winner

Product Information

Beyond his mountaineering books, he wrote "Where the Bong Tree Grows," an account of a year he spent traveling through some of the most remote islands of the South Pacific. After an exhausting climb and close to the summit, a fellow climber is injured through sheer hubris. Rudi, desperate for the glory of being the first man to ever reach the peak and eager to complete his father’s last journey, is torn. Does he fulfill what he sees as his destiny and summit the peak, or does he follow the code of the mountain guides and care for his incapacitated climbing partner? His own father knew what it meant to belong to the mountains – and died there not from an accident, but of exposure when he stayed with an injured client and was caught in a storm while waiting for help.

The extraordinary difficulty of making this film on the Matterhorn was chronicled in the "Perilous Assignments" episode of Walt Disney Presents. I liked the very ending especially (where he had disappeared to go and take care of the dishes), for two reasons. One, that despite the times he had been disobedient and had lied to his mother and uncle and shirked his other duties, he had changed. This simple action proved again that he was a true guide of Kurtal, that he had changed and was more mature. He proved that he had integrity. He had made a promise, and he was going to follow through.

Currently Reading

Rudi understands why his mother forbids him to follow his father's profession, even though her brother - Rudi's Uncle Franz - is one of Kurtal's most successful guides. Rudi will learn the hotel business, first in Kurtal and later in Zurich. His mother has already given one man to the Citadel and its fabled demons. She won't risk giving another. But Rudi can't help himself. He has to climb. When he meets another famous English mountaineer, Captain John Winter - and proves his strength and skill by saving Winter's life - it's only a matter of time. The Citadel waits to be climbed, and Josef Matt's son knows he's the man who must climb it. I thought that this Newbery honor book was going to be just another boy's historical adventure, and that I'd get fed up with it and choose to DNF. I was wrong.

In 1865, an Englishman by the name of Edward Whymper became the first man to climb the mountain in the Swiss Alps known as the Matterhorn. Until then, the Matterhorn was thought to be unconquerable and indeed it took the lives of four of Whymper’s companions during the difficult and treacherous descent. Ullman took inspiration from this real-life account when he penned his fictional work, Banner in the Sky. The book tells the story of the first climbing of an intimidating mountain in the Swiss Alps named the Citadel; a mountain that has also claimed the lives of those who have tried to reach its tantalizing summits. Among those who perished in the attempt was a man named Josef Matt (with an obvious nod of the head to the real mountain). Banner in the Sky tells the story of his son, Rudi and his dream of one day climbing the mountain on which his father perished. This was a hard book to put down! For those adventurous souls that like to read about daring and do, this is a gutsy mountain climbing story that provides some good moral lessons to discuss too. Given the story’s focus, it is no surprise the amount of detail given to the mountain itself. The book spends paragraphs devoted to describing all the mountains edges and cliffs, and the difficulty in climbing them. The climbing itself is so vividly described that it is no surprise that the author himself is an avid mountaineer. This can at times, seemingly lag the story behind as the descriptions never seem to end.Attitudes/Disobedience - 16 Incidents: A boy is described as playing "truant from school - even from church," running out on the job, and not caring that it causes his mother "tears." A boy asks someone not to tell anyone that he came to visit, noting that his parents would be mad. Lying: a man lies to cover for a boy not being at work. A boy is called on a lie, and continues to lie. A man lies to a mother about what her son is really doing (so she won't worry). Lying: a boy says he's not tired but he really is. A boy's lie "caught up with him." "Not a result of conscious choice or decision, it was simply what he had to do," describing the boys defiance to his mother and disobedience. When a man finds out that a boy lied, he smiles for a minute, but then gets serious about the effects of the lie. An uncle discusses how his nephew disobeyed, defied, thieved, connived, lied. A man then tell him that he and his mother drove the boy to it. A man discusses how he was lied to by the boy, but that the boy "meant no harm" and only did "what he had to do". "Right and wrong did not matter. Nothing in all the world mattered, except that he must go." "You lied to me." The film was based on the 1954 novel Banner in the Sky by James Ramsey Ullman, who had written The White Tower. The novel was based on the real life first ascent of the Matterhorn in 1865. [3] Captain John Winter was based on Edward Whymper but the young character of Rudi was entirely fictional. The New York Times called it "a superb mountain climbing story for younger readers". [4] Development [ edit ] W. C. Handy's Life Screens: Nat (King) Cole Sings Blues in Toned-Down Music Film Scheuer, Philip K. Los Angeles Times April 24, 1958: B9.

It is an adventure. It is about a world which was not relevant to women. But it's about a 16 yo boy who, through the course of the book, becomes a man. And it's cleanly, crisply written, easy enough to read that I stayed up way past my bedtime and finished it. Banner in the Sky takes place in 1865 and is the story of sixteen year old Rudi Matt. Rudi lives in the village of Kurtal in the middle of the Swiss Alps. He feels a powerful pull to climb the mountains surrounding his village and desperately wants to be a mountain guide like his uncle is and his father was. Unfortunately, his father was killed when Rudi was young. He had tried to climb The Citadel, which had never been climbed and was thought unclimbable by most people. Rudi's mother, wanting to make sure that her son isn't killed in the mountains like her husband was, keeps Rudi out of the mountains. Instead he works as a dishwasher in a village hotel. However, a series of chance encounters create a situation in which Rudi defies his mother and joins a group of mountaineers who are trying to be the first to climb The Citadel. Incidentally, Ullman based the book on the first successful climb of The Matterhorn in Switzerland. (Picture below) Set in 1865 in the fictional town of Kurtal (aka Zermatt), we meet our hero, sixteen-year-old Rudi Matt, as a disgruntled dishwasher at the town’s best hotel. Slight and cherubic, Rudi is nothing like the bulk of the town’s hearty men, who make their livings as guides for mountain-climbing tourists. He is, his mother and uncle have decided, to be a hotelier and to train in Zurich after getting experience at home. They want him far away from the dangerous mountains that have taken too many men from their town, his own father included. The 1950s was a golden era for children’s adventure tales and Ullman exemplifies the best of the tradition, writing suspenseful scenes along with solid character development. The book is full of climbing action and it is wonderfully vivid and tense, carrying the reader along with Rudi through his painful and dangerous exploits. As someone who hates heights, climbing is my idea of torture and I mean it as a compliment to Ullman’s skill that certain scenes made me queasy. What an idiotic pastime – but what good material for an adventure tale. James Donald fell eighteen feet off a crag shooting a scene but escaped with minor injuries. Assistant cameraman Pierre Tairraz fell in a crevasse and broke three ribs. [1]He also wrote the short story "Top Man", a story about mountaineers climbing K3, a mountain in India. His works include Banner in the Sky, which was a book based on the true story of the first climbing of the Matterhorn (it was filmed in Switzerland as Third Man on the Mountain), and The White Tower (which would star Glenn Ford and Lloyd Bridges). A timeless outdoor adventure story, winner of a Newbery Honor, that will appeal to fans of Hatchet and Jon Krakauer's Into the Wild and Into Thin Air. He was the ghost writer for Tenzing Norgay's autobiography Man of Everest (originally published as Tiger of the Snows). High Conquest was the first of nine books for J.B. Lippincott coming out in 1941 followed by The White Tower, River of The Sun, Windom's Way, and Banner in the Sky which was a 1955 Newbery Hon James Ramsey Ullman (1907–1971) was an American writer and mountaineer. He was born in New York. He was not a high end climber, but his writing made him an honorary member of that circle. Some of his writing is noted for being "nationalistic," e.g., The White Tower.

But Rudi is a mountaineer in his heart, and escapes the kitchen to climb whenever he can. He may never have known his father, the great Josef Matt who died on an expedition to summit the Citadel (aka the Matterhorn), the last great unconquered peak in Switzerland, but he inherited his spirit. Not many good character qualities are exhibited by the main character. In fact, whenever there is lying, or inappropriate behavior, it is dismissed or even explained in a positive light. "It was simply what he had to do" was used to justify his actions. Only at the very end, does the boy do the right thing. It's a great story of mountaineering, so perhaps for older kids or for younger but with a parent discussion. A mother says that it isn't wrong that her son lied to her, but that she was wrong for "making" the son lie.

Blog Stats

I hope I have inspired you to read Banner in the Sky or to give it to the young reader in your household. I know all too well that supplying a voracious reader with excellent and age-appropriate material can be challenging at times. This book, as one of the best-kept secrets in literature, is worth purchasing and I would specifically recommend it for children around the age of 12. It is also, like all excellent children’s literature, a very enjoyable read even if your age is many times that number—and especially if you are one of those well-read readers who could use a wake-up call from an obscure work to shake off some snobbishness. The entire cast and crew, numbering 170, did a course in mountaineering before filming began on June 23, 1958. [1] James Ramsey Ullman (August 21, 1907 – June 20, 1971) was an American writer and mountaineer. [1] He was born in New York City. He was not a "high end" climber, but his writing made him an honorary member of that circle. This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. He was the ghost writer for Tenzing Norgay's autobiography Man of Everest (originally published as Tiger of the Snows). High Conquest was the first of nine books for J.B. Lippincott coming out in 1941 followed by The White Tower, River of The Sun, Windom's Way, and Banner in the Sky which was a 1955 Newbery Honor book. All of these titles became major motion pictures.