Ordinary Human Failings: The heart-breaking, unflinching, compulsive new novel from the author of Acts of Desperation

Product Information

In quello spazio sperava che i contorni delle scuse che le aveva rivolto anni prima, così trascurabili nella loro forma parlata, diventassero evidenti e concreti. Le scuse che ancora non riusciva a esprimere in modo eloquente, quelle che non sarebbero mai finite e che lei rivolgeva a Lucy e alla bambina a cui aveva tolto la vita, e a se stessa, ogni mattina che si svegliava, pensando, Mi dispiace, mi dispiace, mi dispiace”…. This second novel has a larger cast of leading characters, and this is welcome. The extended Green family provide a context for the main protagonist, Carmel, who would otherwise have been a straightforward extension of the nameless narrator in Acts of Desperation. Then there’s tabloid reporter Tom Hargreaves whose journalism career provides a well worked adjunct to the family drama unfolding. Nolan describes the Greens as having “ordinary human failings, tragedies too routine to be of note”. But in this deeply tender book, she not only notes those tragedies, she also bears witness to them. To do so is an act of compassion. To do so with such grace is a genuine achievement. Nolan in her very open interviews. Each review in the UK national press reveals different elements of Nolan’s personal battles.

Finally there’s Rose. She’s John’s beatific, underappreciated second wife, Carmel’s mother and de facto mother to Lucy. Rose’s death – which occurs early in the narrative – along with the alcoholism, creeping anti-Irish sentiment and the Greens’ collective disbelief in their own potential goodness – mires the family. It’s also a book about the absence of affection, and how that can mark you. It’s also about emigration and loneliness, about some of the issues facing women in Ireland. I absolutely Megan Nolan's last book, Acts of Desperation, which was one of my books of the year 2021.Impressive and sad story about growing up in an estate, class, poverty, alcoholism, trauma throughout generations, and shame. Where you grow up, what family you come from, what class you are; this all forms you and determines the opportunities you’ll get in life, and your future. It’s almost impossible to change the life you was born into. It’s what you know, what you’ve learned and experienced. Nolan writes about all this with great insight and empathy, and this novel really moved me. I thought the character of Tom wasn’t of great importance to the story though. MyHome.ie (Opens in new window) • Top 1000 • The Gloss (Opens in new window) • Recruit Ireland (Opens in new window) • Irish Times Training (Opens in new window) There’s a scene in the book where Richie goes on the drink, and you can see exactly what’s going to happen. It’s a bit of a minor heartbreak that you know decides the direction that lives can take. It’s a perfectly described scene that had me feeling the fear even before Richie did.

I’m sure I’m not alone in being slightly anxious that the story was going to be taken up with the death of a young child, but the story doesn’t go down that road. Rather, it’s a book about the secrets that people carry around with them, the private suffering hidden just below the surface. Carmel Consigliato a chi predilige le storie introspettive e a chi non dispiace immergersi nei drammi famigliari.Sarebbe bastato soffermarsi sul titolo per comprendere il nucleo di quello che, a tutti gli effetti, è un romanzo familiare camuffato da thriller. The tabloid storyline is less compelling, and an encounter between Tom and Carmel, which feels like an attempt to bring the book’s two strands together, strikes a brief false note. Far better to approach Ordinary Human Failings as literary fiction than as a whodunnit. “There is no secret, Tom, or else there are hundreds of them, and none of them interesting enough for you,” says Carmel. “The secret is that we’re a family, we’re just an ordinary family, with ordinary unhappiness like yours.” Readers will revel in the delicate construction of Nolan’s sentences and fine attunement to the family’s inner lives: Carmel’s dignity, Rose’s sacrifice, John’s humiliation, Richie’s despair. One of the things I really liked about this book is that you really feel that some of the characters change. It’s fine for an author to say that a character has developed, but I really felt that Carmel reached an understanding, that there was a growth from her experiences. It felt both natural and satisfying. In the same vein, another of the characters didn’t, and disappeared into his own personal, comfortable sadness, and that felt genuine too.

I was talking with a friend lately about an impulse many writers have, not least myself, to finish pieces like this one with some ill-earned flourish of moral clarity. “All articles,” I said, “end in one of two ways: ‘And at the end of the day, who cares?’ or ‘At the end of the day, love is what matters.’” I am trying to resist that impulse. I am trying to avoid casting my indecision about what constitutes happiness as its own kind of moral victory. I am not going to smugly advise that the key to happiness lies in accepting its transience. Ordinary Human Failings is a novel about an Irish family and their lives uncovered as one of them is accused of killing a small girl on a London estate. In 1990, tabloid journalist Tom Hargreaves is investigating the disappearance of a young girl who then turns up dead, and the finger of blame is pointed at Lucy, who lives with her Irish immigrant family: her aloof mother Carmel, alcoholic uncle, and reclusive grandfather. As he gets closer to the family, he tries to unravel their stories into something resembling a news story, but that might not be the way it is going. It’s often quoted, but Tolstoys ‘All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way’ really resonates in this book. And as Carmel says to Tom at one stage The event that sets in motion Megan Nolan’s second novel is a chilling one – the murder of a minor, seemingly at the hands of another child. Ordinary Human Failings, predominantly set in early-90s London, opens with a frantic investigation to uncover what happened to three-year-old Mia Enright. Her crumpled, bruised body is found by a rubbish chute in the Nunhead council estate where she lived. Neighbours say they last saw her playing with Lucy Green, the unpredictable 10-year-old daughter of an Irish family that has long been the source of xenophobic suspicion amongst the residents of Skyler Square. When a young girl in a London council estate dies, rumors start to fly about the Green family. After all, the girl was last seen playing with their daughter Lucy. And hasn’t Lucy always been a bit odd? Her mother Carmel is never around, her Uncle Richie a barely functioning alcoholic, and the Grandad John is reclusive and detached.We also hear from Carmel’s late mother, Rose, who looked after Lucy in light of Carmel’s indifference; her hermetic and rageful father, John, who had been abandoned by his first wife; and her alcoholic half-brother, Richie. “Who would care about a family like theirs?” Carmel wonders as the police embark on their investigation. “Theirs were ordinary human failings, tragedies too routine to be of note.” Ordinary Human Failings, a novel about truth prejudice, family and secrets, to be published by Jonathan Cape in June 2023, was originally acquired as the second title in a two-book deal, with Acts of Desperation being the first. It's 1990 in London and Tom Hargreaves has it all: a burgeoning career as a reporter, fierce ambition and a brisk disregard for the "peasants" - ordinary people, his readers, easy tabloid fodder. His star looks set to rise when he stumbles across a scoop: a dead child on a London estate, grieving parents loved across the neighbourhood, and the finger of suspicion pointing at one reclusive family of Irish immigrants and 'bad apples': the Greens.

At the heart of things is Carmel, a young woman who is “boiling inside”. Her sweeping teenage romance with twentysomething Derek ends when he leaves for Dublin. Shortly after, Carmel finds she is pregnant with Lucy. This prompts the family’s move to England, to escape shame and start afresh. This is the story of the murder of a little girl, Mia. A young woman of the neighborhood is suspected of the murder. They live in a poor community, so there’s class commentary throughout the novel (or what I read). In particular, you follow a journalist character who is covering the murder, and the patronizing way he approaches the people of the community is highlighted. The novel includes his articles, showing how the media smears the poor. We get the POV of Carmel (Lucy’s mother), Richie (Carmel’s brother) and Tom (Carmel’s father) as they pull apart the threads of their lives that brought the family to this point, from their origins in Waterford. This is a family story but also a commentary on social inequality and how the smallest of events can can tip an ordinary family into decline out of which it becomes nigh on impossible to claw.The character that I most enjoyed is Richie. It’s not easy to write a character who has been so totally overwhelmed by alcohol dependency, and retain some reader empathy. Nolan manages to do this. His primary fear is of loneliness and isolation: The subject matter is tough and none of it is exactly a bundle of laughs. Megan Nolan doesn’t go in for fairy story endings for either her characters or the novel itself. The main theme of the book was well conveyed, and it is that devoting love, and time, to a child does not come easily to everybody.