Virtues of Vulnerability: Humility, Autonomy, and Citizen-Subjectivity

Product Information

Without fail, everyone who was interviewed for this story brought up the issue of a candidate’s spouse. Figuring out if a candidate has a spouse who also requires a job at the institution is one of the biggest hurdles faced during hiring. After all, “83 percent of women in STEM have partners who are academic scientists,” notes Rushing. You have the right to call that person out and say, ‘That’s an illegal question. I don’t want to answer that.’ But, realistically, how you answer that question determines what happens next,” says Alexandra Tracy–Ramirez, an attorney with the law firm HopkinsWay who works with individuals who have experienced harassment or discrimination.

In the final quatrain of the poem the speaker asks that her lover, “plunge [her] deep in love.” This line supports the previous supposition that she desires a love that both consumes her but also makes her feel as if she is finally free of the confines of her life. In the next set of four lines, the speaker redirects her words to her intended listener. She wants to make sure this person understands what she has to say. The speaker begins by making sure her listener knows that she understands their feelings. This person loves her, but that fact doesn’t make her emotions irrelevant. She needs more than love. In the next two lines, the speaker defines what it is she really means when she says she wants to be “lost.” In her mind, the state of being she is looking for would resemble a “candle lit at noon.” This image has been chosen as the light from the candle would be accomplishing nothing. The sun is up at noon and a lit candle would be superfluous, but still burning on, unsure of its place. in teaching, defined as " the set of activities performed by faculty that fosters student learning, critical Candidates and hiring managers interviewed for this article report that the illegal and inappropriate questions tend to come up during the social moments of campus interviews, such as meals and receptions. Candidates know that anything they say at any time could get noted in their applications. But social events during recruitment visits are intentionally more casual than sit-down interviews, and faculty members often ask personal questions as they might at gatherings without job candidates.Butler, Judith. 2000. Antigone’s Claim: Kinship Between Life and Death. New York: Columbia University Press. But in trying to find out if there’s a spouse involved, hiring committees can end up asking an illegal question. Unfortunately, there is no way for a candidate to gauge whether having a spouse is a help or hindrance to the hiring process. For example, Ross is certain that when she and her husband were interviewing for faculty positions 10 years ago, one institution bypassed her for another woman who didn’t have a spouse who needed a job. So broaching the topic of a spouse is an awkward dance between the candidate and head of the department. Then there is the art of interpreting job applications. Rushing says, “You have to understand that women may not toot their own horns in the same way as men. When you read letters of recommendation, you have to understand that the language used to assess a woman may be different from the language used to assess a man. That’s the problem with the letter writer, but it’s something for which the committee can control.”

Salih, Sara. 2003. “Judith Butler and the Ethics of ‘difficulty’.” Critical Quarterly 45 (3): 42–51.Butler, Judith. 2015b. Notes Toward a Performative Theory of Assembly. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. One way those who ask illegal or inappropriate questions defend their behavior, Tracy–Ramirez says, is by saying something along the lines of “I just wanted to get some information and make sure the person was a good fit.” Candidates use this 30-minute segment of their interview to learn about how the university supports work–life balance and ask all the questions that they can’t ask members of the search committee. “The family advocate has no interest in who’s getting hired in this search. Often we don’t even remember what search they are part of!” says Rushing, who is one of two family advocates on campus. “We can tell them about dual hiring in Montana State. We can tell them about our modified duties for faculty for family caregiving. We can tell them about our tenure extension policies. They can ask all the questions that they are perhaps not inclined to ask members of the search committee: What are the real estate prices like? What’s it like to be gay in Montana?” Catherine is a postdoctoral fellow with an NIH career-transition award who asked that her real name not to be used. She earned her Ph.D. at the University of Chicago in the same department as Lieb but under a different adviser.

Sara Rushing, Political Science Outstanding Teaching Award for Teaching Excellence in Classroom and Laboratory Teaching In the first stanza of ‘ I Am Not Yours’ the speaker begins by utilizing the line which would become the title of the poem, “I am not yours…” This strong and unwavering statement comes across less like an opinion than a fact which the speaker will not be changing her mind on. Butler, Judith. 2012. Parting Ways: Jewishness and the Critique of Zionism. New York: Columbia University Press. Panel chairs often fail to paint the picture of a competent professional, instead lingering much longer than in the case of male speakers on the women’s physical attributes, age, country of upbringing, family situation and so on. Even well-meaning, jovial endorsements of a woman’s nonprofessional attributes —“how nice to see X, Y, Z in a discussion of such a serious topic”— can be distracting at best. At worst, such comments outright undermine the speaker.

Become a member!

A substantial component of the theoretical analysis in The Virtues of Vulnerability is wrestling with the way that choice and freedom are presented within the medical environment but are delimited in what we can actually choose and what we understand and know about these choices as well. This concept of freedom and choice are also connected to the way that neoliberalism frames our experiences, thus we perceive of our autonomy in these medicalized environments through the appearance of choices we get to make, or options provided to us, but often these are actually quite narrow in scope, constrained by the demands of health insurance and healthcare/medical marketplace. Rushing’s analysis gets at these many competing dimensions of healthcare and how it is operationalized, leading the reader to consider how we experience our interactions and how we might reconsider our autonomy within these environments by understanding how our vulnerability and humility can help us work more collaboratively with those who are engaging in this ethics of care with us. A substantial component of the theoretical analysis in The Virtues of Vulnerability is wrestling with the way that choice and freedom are presented within the medical environment but are delimited in what we can actually choose and what we understand and know about these choices as well. This concept of freedom and choice are also connected to the way that neoliberalism frames our experiences, thus we perceive of our autonomy in these medicalized environments through the appearance of choices we get to make, or options provided to us, but often these are actually quite narrow in scope, constrained by the demands of health insurance and healthcare/medical marketplace. Rushing’s analysis gets at these many competing dimensions of healthcare and how it is operationalized, leading the reader to consider how we experience our interactions and how we might reconsider our autonomy within these environments by understanding how our vulnerability and humility can help us work more collaboratively with those who are engaging in this ethics of care with us. We asked people who withdrew from (job) searches before or after an offer was made and found that women were likely to do so because they had been asked these questions,” says Abigail Stewart, a professor of psychology and women’s studies at the University of Michigan. She was the senior author on the JAMA paper and the director of the university’s ADVANCE program.

Zach Rushing, the top earning multi-talented personality, had also been a popular football player while he was in college. The performance started with the football at D’lberville High, and then he continued with it in college. Also, he was the winner in the match with Grand Rapids Community College. Zach Rushing Social Media handles During the Community Fun Day, Rushing says that she saw vendors and church staff praying with community members. Then, on Sunday, Rushing says she noticed many new faces in the service — people who had attended the Community Fun Day. Butler, Judith. 1993. Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of ‘Sex’. New York and London: Routledge. Derrida, Jacques. 1988. “Signature, Event, Context.” In Limited, Inc, edited by Gerald Graff. Trans. Samuel Weber and Jeffrey Mehlman, 1–24. Evanston: Northwestern University Press. Jessi Bennion, Political Science Outstanding Teaching Award for Teaching Excellence That Serves MSU's Land Grant MissionBiases and discriminatory moves aren’t limited to the campus interviews. (See box on “Five don’t’s for introducing a female speaker (and why this matters).”) Biases and discrimination can pervade the entire hiring process. She also urges people to think deeply about why they like a particular candidate and to make sure they are not resorting to assumptions and stereotypes. People came from Florida just to see Zach performing on the stage. Moreover, he is also famous for making controversial statements that open a way for fans to talk with him. And sometimes the questions are insensitive. In February, the story of molecular biologist Jason Lieb’s resignation from the University of Chicago broke. Lieb resigned after the university recommended he be fired for sexual misconduct with female graduate students.